Practice of billing Medicare to fix droopy lids raises eyebrows
The public health insurance program typically does not cover cosmetic surgery, but for cases in which a patient’s sagging eyelids significantly hinder their vision, it does pay to have them lifted. In recent years, though, a rapid rise in the number of so-called functional eyelid lifts, or blepharoplasty, has led some to question whether Medicare is letting procedures that are really cosmetic slip through the cracks – at a cost of millions of dollars.
Plastic surgeons say there are a number of legitimate reasons for the spike, including a tendency among the elderly to seek fixes for real medical issues they might have quietly suffered through even a decade ago. But surgeons also acknowledge an increased awareness of the surgery fueled by reality television, word-of-mouth referrals and advertising that promises a more youthful appearance. And doctors concede they face increased pressure from patients to perform eyelid lifts, even when they do not meet Medicare’s requirement that peripheral vision actually be impaired.
John LiVecchi, a Florida plastic surgeon, who has had an eyelid lift himself, disputes that patients are flocking to the procedure primarily with vanity in mind. Patients with droopy eyelids often don’t realize how much the droopy skin is narrowing their field of vision, he said. LiVecchi said he jokes with his patients that he doesn’t want them driving in his neighborhood until after the surgery. “It’s safer for society,” he said.
The benefits of functional eyelid surgery for some patients are documented. A 2011 study published in the journal Ophthalmology, for example, found that the surgery provided “significant improvement in vision, peripheral vision, and quality of life activities.”
Published June 2013
- Q: If I have my lids done, will I be able to close my eyes properly?Q: If I have my lids done, will I be able to close my eyes properly? A: An upper lid blepharoplasty should remove just enough redundant skin from the upper lids to reveal a nice lid fold. If excessive skin is removed, patients may be unable to close their eyes properly.
- Q: I know I need a facelift but what can I do about my heavy eyelids?Q: I know I need a facelift but what can I do about my heavy eyelids? A: When considering a facelift for your cheeks and neck, it is important to consider your eye area as well. Droopy or sleepy-looking upper eyelids and excessive “baggage” on the lower lids are quite common
- I want my nose improved but I still want to look like me.Most patients want improvement – not change. Many patients in my practice voice a concern about having plastic surgery that they feel might make them look like someone else. After years of looking at yourself in the mirror or of your family and friends looking at you it is normal
- Q: I am a 50-year old man and generally feel I have an aged and tired appearance. Would a facelift be suitable for me?Q: I am a 50-year old man. I don’t regard myself as old but I have sagging jowls, a bit of a double chin and generally feel I have an aged and tired appearance. Would a facelift be suitable for me? A: Men are also feeling the pressure of normal ageing—the
- I look tired and I’m often asked what I’m worried about. What can I do about this?Q: I look tired and I’m often asked what I’m worried about. What can I do about this? A: A tired or angry appearance is associated with brow ptosis (i.e. drooping). The eyebrows have begun to undergo the effects of gravity and instead of being